This is a trope I see in a LOT of slash I read, either original or fanfiction. There are several traits she can have--
- Being one of the only people who knows about the couple, or the only one to accept them
- "Knowing" or "having a feeling" long before she's told or officially finds out
- Expresses some form of fangirlism--makes some mention of them both not being hard on the eye, smirking/winking/giggling at some romantic scene unfolding
- Falls into the Mother Hen trope of nagging, handing out advice, protecting/defending the boys from persecution
- Usually the confidante for one of the guys that first has the crush (falls into "knew all along" as well)
- Always has some form of women's intuition; may end up nagging the boys for lacking it: "Like, duh, it's totally obvious he likes you!" etc. etc.
I'm sure there's more that falls into the trope, but that's how I usually see it pan out.
See... I don't mind this trope, honestly. It's just that I see it so freaking often, and in the case of fanfiction, there are characters that get turned into this trope and that's where I have to go "Okay, no, I cannot see this happening. Just no."
But there's also the fact that I NEVER see one of the guys have a competent
male confidante, or god forbid, a
gay male confidante. I feel like a mother hen would probably end up annoying some guys in a pairing--some people just don't like someone doting over them or cooing over their private matters, shockingly. Why can't one of the boys have a confidante that's as emotionally withdrawn as a guy, even if she still is female, but she's not so bloody invested in the relationship. Some people prefer sound, logical advice to the advice that comes from people who only cite intuition.
Or how about we change it up, eh? Can we have a female who protects their secret (should their relationship need to be a secret) but doesn't necessarily approve of the relationship for whatever reason? This would make sense if they secret needs to be kept because of the society they live in--if the female friend grew up in that same society, she may have some values that's reflected in that society and probably won't realize it until she catches her guy friends having a shag and gets squicked out by it. Can we have her have some character development where she slowly realizes that two males can have a good relationship, or at least come to terms with it?
I think it would be more interesting to see a heterosexual guy friend be one of the guy's confidantes. Like SUPER heterosexual but also really accepting in an "heh, okay, bro *knuckle bump*" kind of way, hahaha. You could make him as dumb or as smart as you want, but come on, not all heterosexual men have their head screwed on backwards or are TOTALLY squicked out by anything gay. The occasional wince or "I didn't need to know that" proceeded with a light-hearted laugh may be all that's needed, or maybe even not. Some guys are cool, slash writers!
Gay/bi/whatever male friend! This is also something I so rarely see. Who better to understand your problems as a gay/bi/whatever guy in a relationship with a guy? He actually knows the dynamics, more so than an Understanding Female does. I can see a lot of personalities coming from a dynamic like this--I especially like the idea of the older giving advice to the younger, or someone who's in a long-term relationship already, or even someone who the guy probably shouldn't be getting advice from at all since the friend has never been in a long-term relationship but sleeps around a lot, or maybe someone who's just in the same boat he is. Anything, really, and I think it could really work. You just need to turn off your god damn slash goggles and stop seeing as every male with a close relationship as having romantic undertones, even if both of them are gay. Some people are just friends, slashers, mmkay? And that's perfectly okay, and you can so easily make them just friends without bringing in unneeded sexual tension between them. (Or you can have them be past lovers--now THAT would be interesting.)
Then there's also the route of having a female who isn't a total mother hen but still listens to all the boy's problem. Just have her not be so "Oh I knew the whole time" and dishing out what she thinks the boys should do even when it isn't asked. I'd like to see her as a lesbian or something, just because again it would have that special understanding going on, but really, anyone will do. I'm just tired of all females being so damn perceptive--can't we have some of them just be like... as emotionally invested in the relationship as
normal people are concerning their friend's relationships?
It's not that I mind the trope... I'm just tired of seeing it and would like writers to change things up a bit. Oh, and for fanfiction, not to choose their designated Understanding Female unless the characters in question already have an established relationship of the female acting as a confidante or mother hen to one or both of the boys, and also has super female perceiving powers. Canon, people: I like there to be some back up. I also don't like the idea that you
have to have the Understanding Female, because that does seem to be the mindset with how often she creeps up in the crap I read.
EDIT: Actually, I will say that I can very well do without the fangirl element that manages to crop up, even in the better stories. It's just... creepy. Unless the girl is known for being flirtatious--and even then--it would probably rub most people off the wrong way if they commenting on how omg hot they and their boyfriend were together, or how hot their boyfriend was, etc. etc. It's sort of like "ooookaaay I didn't invite you to a threeway, there. Back off, plz." That just kind of makes the whole invasive quality of the trope even worse to me, I guess, and the absence of the fangirlism is much preferred. Not to mention it makes the whole relationship so gimmicky to have onlookers from the outside going "Oh aren't they just so cute and sexy together?" It's like, um, yeah, they are, that's why I'm reading it and you're writing it. Why are you confirming this to me, author?
Point is, friends... generally do not say those kinds of things, at least no one I know does. Maybe some do, but I can still see it rubbing some people off the wrong way. You're friends, which means you want to see them in a purely platonic way, which means you don't WANT to imagine them doing anything sexual. At all. Even if they're both hot and they're both men and you're a woman who likes men. "They make a cute couple" is one thing, but near voyeurism is not okay.[/rant]